“Jim is a consummate professional. He creates the environment for a successful mediation and pursues all avenues to reach that end. My colleagues and I have utilized him several times and have great respect for his efforts.”

-Gregory R. Neuhauser • Senior Deputy Attorney General

“Although it appeared that settlement was not possible, (Jim Gibbons’) diligence kept the parties talking and ultimately paved the way for a resolution of the case. (His) excellent advice and insights proved instrumental.”

-Jay Barry Harris • Esquire, Fineman Krekstein & Harris • Philadelphia, Pa

“My insurance company clients and I have utilized Judge Gibbons as both a mediator and an arbitrator on many occasions and have found him to be well-prepared, thorough in his analysis, accommodating to both sides with discovery issues and scheduling, as well as being an evaluator who consistently places cases within a range of value that, in my experience, is ultimately satisfactory to not just my clients, but actually to both parties. I have also found his fees to be reasonable and fair. I highly recommend Judge Gibbons services as a mediator and/or an arbitrator.”

-Attorney Dan Cummins • Foley, Cognetti, Comerford, Cimini & Cummins • Scranton, Pa

“I have worked with Atty. Gibbons when he has served as mediator or arbitrator on many occasions and no one works harder to get a fair result for the parties.  He is extremely dedicated to the process of resolving the cases in a timely and efficient matter.  He goes the extra mile.  I highly recommend him!!”

Gregory E. Fellerman, Esquire • Fellerman & Ciarimboli Law, PC

“Magistrate Judge James Gibbons has served as an arbitrator and/or mediator in many cases in which our office has been involved.  His mediation skills as well as his competence in all aspects of the alternative dispute resolution process rank him as one of the most effective arbitrators/mediators in our area.  I high recommend Judge Gibbons for his expertise in this regard.”

- Richard G. Fine, Esquire

“I have agreed to Attorney Gibbons, without hesitation, as both a Mediator and Neutral Arbitrator on numerous occasions in many complex matters.  He has always been extremely well-prepared and fair to all parties. His background as a former US Attorney, trial lawyer and Magistrate brings a unique perspective to his case handling. His integrity and reputation among his peers is beyond reproach.”

- Attorney George E. Saba, Jr.

“We all agree that, in personal injury litigation, mediation has become an integral part of the process.  However, it can sometimes be challenging to find a mediator upon whom both sides can agree.

Having litigated on both sides of the fence in personal injury matters, Judge Gibbons brings with him a unique, well rounded, and unbiased perspective that gives us litigants the assurance that both the strengths and weaknesses of our respective positions will be frankly discussed and fairly analyzed.  Judge Gibbons has the respect of both the Plaintiffs’ bar and the Defense bar alike and is an invaluable asset in the ADR arena.”

-Charles A. Dominick, Esquire

“Jim Gibbons possesses all the right stuff when it comes to mediations and arbitrations. Our office has used Jim when we’ve represented Plaintiffs and Defendants, and he is even-handed, knowledgeable and diligent.  He follows through and gives every case his undivided attention.  He is always well prepared and relates well to everyone in the room. I recommend Jim Gibbons highly for all types of cases.”

-Attorney Joseph G. Price • Dougherty,Leventhal & Price

Having mediated some very complex cases with numerous mediators over the years, I can unequivocally say that James Gibbons ” gets it” when it comes to mediation. He does what a mediator is supposed to do- promote and continue dialogue with the mediation participants both attorneys and clients. He is very skilled at maneuvering parties through obstacles ( issues) that generally presents themselves as potential roadblocks during every mediation. He is committed to the process of resolution and works very hard at it.

- Attorney Richard Jurewicz  • Galfand & Berger • Philadelphia

“It has been my distinct pleasure to mediate/arbitrate numerous cases before (Jim Gibbons) over the past several years. While I have not agreed with every outcome, each time my clients and I have come away knowing that (he) reviewed the matter thoroughly and rendered (his) level and best judgment. I remain particularly impressed with (his) detailed knowledge of the facts of each of those cases, and the strengths and weaknesses of the parties’ respective positions.”

-Attorney Neil T. O’Donnell, Kingston, Pa

“Jim Gibbons’ background and demeanor make him uniquely qualified to sit as a Mediator. He instills into the process a sense of fairness. I have taken difficult clients before Jim, and he has been able to deal with them and address their concerns. His methods are timely and professional. There have been times when Jim has contacted me weeks and months after a stalled mediation to tell me that he has reopened negotiations. He has then seen those through to resolution. I would recommend Jim’s mediation service to anyone as I have always felt that both sides receive fair treatment from an impartial professional.”

-Attorney Daniel W. Munley, Scranton, Pa

“I have utilized Jim Gibbons’ mediation services on both plaintiff’s cases and cases for the various insurance carriers I represent. He is consistent, fair, open minded and balanced in his approach. I am mostly impressed with his innate ability to relate to the litigants on a personal level regardless of their station in life. His intellect allows him to master very complex cases quickly and this has been critical in resolving  important matters through his mediation.

His ability to follow up on cases with counsel after the initial mediation has been very successful.

His track record is unparalleled in helping to resolve matters. I recommend him constantly to my clients.”

-Harry T. Coleman, Esquire • Carbondale, Pa

“There comes a time in most cases when it makes sense for the parties to sit down and talk.  In Northeastern PA, it is difficult to find a respected and trusted intermediary amenable to both sides. Judge Gibbons is that person. He is always well prepared at the mediations, and clearly has read the materials provided by the parties.  I trust that my direct communications with him are held in confidence.  He offers me and my client candid comments about the case.

I believe it was Abraham Lincoln who said ” It is also often said that the sign of a good settlement or resolution is that both parties are not entirely happy with the result but the case is still nevertheless finally resolved”.  Judge Gibbons works to resolve the case.  If the case does not settle at the mediation session, he does not walk away, but keeps the lines” of communication open.

-Attorney Michael F. Frisbee • Center Valley, Pa